Heat Pump vs Resistive Heater

lgerger

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 11, 2025
Threads
0
Messages
120
Reaction score
121
Vehicles
Tesla Model Y LR
I read somewhere that a heat pump had been confirmed. It seems like it would be a crucial part of an already small battery short range vehicle not losing too much range in adverse weather.
Agreed. This will be a huge consideration.
 

Slashsnake

Member
First Name
Chris
Joined
Jun 9, 2025
Threads
0
Messages
18
Reaction score
11
Location
Minnesota
Vehicles
Model 3. Maverick
Agreed. This will be a huge consideration.
That is a big piece If you live in the cold like I do.

I've got a 300 mile range and a resistive heater and that cold makes a huge difference.

With RWD you obviously would want to be removing those EV friendly tires and putting on some four seasons and losing 10 to 15% of your range.

Then unless they're using the more cutting edge/ expensive batteries for daily driving, you are likely operating in that 20 to 80%.

Then cut 30 to 50% for weather off your range... That's not a lot to work with for every day driving. A heat pump and seat heaters (what I use) can help, but doesn't seem either of those come with standard.
 

GeoLogic

Active Member
Joined
May 16, 2025
Threads
0
Messages
26
Reaction score
20
Location
Eugene, OR
Vehicles
2006 Honda CR-V EX 5-Speed K24A1
Range is lamentably a major issue for those of us in colder locales, such as we in the PNW. For more than half of each year we must drive about using heat, defrost, wipers, and lights all on. Add AWD as I insist on having, and even the extended range battery on the Slate may not be sufficient for reasonable range. I love the Slate concept, but will have to see if the production vehicle is able to yield the range I wish. It may be that I have to await their v2 vehicle, with hope battery technology improves and comes down in price over the time it takes them to develop it.

AWD
SUV Configuration
~250 mile range with all electrical accessories on
Toyota reliability

My CR-V is retained, for as long as it takes, until there's an affordable electric vehicle with these qualities.
 

Benjamin Nead

Active Member
First Name
Ben
Joined
Jun 3, 2025
Threads
0
Messages
31
Reaction score
43
Location
Bisbee, Arizona, USA
Vehicles
2012 Mitsubishi i-MiEV
I just got done in a chat and confirmed, no plans to go with a heat pump. This concerns me as I would think the resistive heat might use more power. but factually don't know that for sure.
It's true: resistance heating elements are going to be overall less efficient than a heat pump. Considerably so in some cases. But for all the cold climate dwellers out there, it's also true that heat pumps start to really struggle at the most frigid of temperatures inside a vehicle's cabin. So, on your coldest Montana winter morning, it's six of one and half a dozen of the other.

All that said, there's been a LOT of research going into heat pumps these past few years. We see the low temperature performance improvements first in residential equipment, like mini-splits and ducted home HVAC systems. Once those products are improved, the tech evolves into smaller scale stuff, for car interiors and residential hot water heating.

Earlier this year, I bought a washer/dryer unit that utilizes a closed loop heat pump system for the drying cycle. The old resistance heat dryer it replaced required a 30A 240V circuit. This new Samsung combo runs everything - washing and drying - off a single 15A 120V outlet. It performs beautifully. The only thing I don't like about it is the overly-complex touch screen interface. So, the Slate simplicity ethic would have been the one improvement I would make to this thing, if I could . . .

Slate Auto Pickup Truck Heat Pump vs Resistive Heater SamsungHeatpumpWashDry_W
 

Slashsnake

Member
First Name
Chris
Joined
Jun 9, 2025
Threads
0
Messages
18
Reaction score
11
Location
Minnesota
Vehicles
Model 3. Maverick
Range is lamentably a major issue for those of us in colder locales, such as we in the PNW. For more than half of each year we must drive about using heat, defrost, wipers, and lights all on. Add AWD as I insist on having, and even the extended range battery on the Slate may not be sufficient for reasonable range. I love the Slate concept, but will have to see if the production vehicle is able to yield the range I wish. It may be that I have to await their v2 vehicle, with hope battery technology improves and comes down in price over the time it takes them to develop it.

AWD
SUV Configuration
~250 mile range with all electrical accessories on
Toyota reliability

My CR-V is retained, for as long as it takes, until there's an affordable electric vehicle with these qualities.
That's true. I have a model 3 (2020, before the heat pump addition) and that 300 miles when you add on 4 season tires (important for me with my AWD, but absolutely necessary for a RWD) instead of the efficient tires, and the cold weather and the 20-80 rule (for everyday driving), 150 miles range is not much. Figure 10% for the tire loss (about what I see) that's 135 miles. 20-80 rule (barring using newer pricier battery tech), that's 80 miles daily usable range. Cut 30-40% for cold weather....

And I get how crazy that sounds but I've got 310 miles of range when I got mine and have had 50 mile drives to get to Minneapolis where when I got home I was a lot closer to empty than I cared to be.
 

metroshot

Well-Known Member
First Name
Pat
Joined
Apr 30, 2025
Threads
1
Messages
111
Reaction score
105
Location
CA
Website
www.kudo-ume-farms.com
Vehicles
Mach E + Honda PHEV
That's true. I have a model 3 (2020, before the heat pump addition) and that 300 miles when you add on 4 season tires (important for me with my AWD, but absolutely necessary for a RWD) instead of the efficient tires, and the cold weather and the 20-80 rule (for everyday driving), 150 miles range is not much. Figure 10% for the tire loss (about what I see) that's 135 miles. 20-80 rule (barring using newer pricier battery tech), that's 80 miles daily usable range. Cut 30-40% for cold weather....

And I get how crazy that sounds but I've got 310 miles of range when I got mine and have had 50 mile drives to get to Minneapolis where when I got home I was a lot closer to empty than I cared to be.
Agree that cold weather is huge detriment for range.

Until we adopt a newer battery tech, the NCM batteries from over a decade ago has not changed much.

Luckily I live in a warm climate year around so I never see range losses in the winter months.

And I charge to 100% every time on L2 or Tesla Superchargers.
 
 
Top